Advanced search×

Episiotomy versus fetal manipulation in managing severe shoulder dystocia: A comparison of outcomes

Edith D ED Gurewitsch, Michele M Donithan, Shawn P SP Stallings, Patricia L PL Moore, Shefali S Agarwal, Leora M LM Allen, and Robert H RH Allen

Am J Obstet Gynecol 191(3):6 (2004) PMID 15467564

ObjectiveIn severe shoulder dystocia, when initial maneuvers fail, either episiotomy or fetal manipulation (Rubin, Woods' screw, or posterior arm release) is recommended. We sought to compare maternal and neonatal outcomes between severe shoulder dystocia deliveries managed with episiotomy versus fetal manipulation.Study designWe identified severe shoulder dystocia deliveries from three databases: all shoulder dystocia deliveries (1993-2003 and 1994-1997) from two teaching institutions and litigated cases of shoulder dystocia-associated permanent brachial plexus palsy from multiple U.S. institutions. Pair-wise comparisons were made among three groups of deliveries: those managed by fetal manipulation without episiotomy (fetal manipulation-only), those managed by episiotomy without fetal manipulation (episiotomy-only), and those managed with both (episiotomy+fetal manipulation). Rates of brachial plexus palsy, neonatal depression, and anal sphincter trauma were compared among groups using @g^2, with significance at P < .05.ResultsAmong episiotomy-only, 13 of 22 (59.1%) sustained brachial plexus palsy, compared with 20 of 57 (35.1%) among fetal manipulation-only (P=.05). Twenty-eight of 48 (58.3%) in episiotomy+fetal manipulation had brachial plexus palsy, which did not differ from episiotomy-only (P=.95) but was higher than fetal manipulation-only (P=.02), suggesting that the addition of episiotomy conferred no benefit in averting neonatal injury. Anal sphincter trauma was significantly more common among episiotomy-only and episiotomy+fetal manipulation, compared with fetal manipulation-only.ConclusionIn severe shoulder dystocia, if fetal manipulation can be performed without episiotomy, severe perineal trauma can be averted without incurring greater risk of brachial plexus palsy.

Copyright © 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

DOI: 10.1016/j.ajog.2004.06.041
Version: za2963e q8zac q8zb2 q8zcd q8zdc q8ze4 q8zff q8zg9

Similar articles you may find interesting…

  1. Brachial plexus palsy in neonates and children.
    G D Eng, B Koch, and M D Smokvina

    Arch Phys Med Rehabil 59(10):458-64 (1978) PMID 309756

    In 135 children with obstetrical palsy, clinical and electrodiagnostic studies on inital and serial evaluation aided in designing a conservative treatment program. Prevention of contractures, maintenance of muscle strength and reinforcing the child's awareness of the affected limb we...
  2. The role of the brachioradialis H reflex in the management and prognosis of obstetrical brachial plexus palsy.
    J T S JT Kao, S S Sharma, ... H M HM Clarke

    Handchir Mikrochir Plast Chir 35(2):106-11 (2003) PMID 12874721

    Our objectives were to document the Brachioradialis H (Br H) reflex latency and amplitude in normal upper extremities of infants, to evaluate the presence or absence of the Br H reflex in obstetrical palsy neonates and infants between one and seven months of age and to determine if this test was a v...
  3. A systematic review of brachial plexus surgery for birth-related brachial plexus injury.
    P Daniel PD McNeely and James M JM Drake

    Pediatr Neurosurg 38(2):57-62 (2003) PMID 12566836

    Twenty-three papers were selected for detailed analysis. There are no randomized controlled trials that have investigated the role of brachial plexus surgery in the management of birth-related brachial plexus palsy. Two prospective studies of relevance were found, one describing the natural history...