Advanced search×

The reliability of and the relation between non-symbolic numerical distance effects in comparison, same-different judgments and priming

Delphine D Sasanguie, Emmy E Defever, Eva E Van den Bussche, and Bert B Reynvoet

Acta Psychol (Amst) 136(1):8 (2011) PMID 21075357

The development of number processing is generally studied by examining the performance on basic number tasks (comparison task, same-different judgment, and priming task). Using these tasks, so-called numerical distance effects are obtained. All these effects are generally explained by assuming a magnitude representation related to a mental number line: magnitudes are represented from left to right with partially overlapping representations for nearby numbers. In this study, we compared the performance of adults on these different tasks using non-symbolic stimuli. First, we investigated whether the effects obtained in these behavioral tasks are reliable. Second, we examined the relation between the three different effects. The results showed that the observed effects in the case of the comparison task and the same-different task proved to be reliable. The numerical distance effect obtained in the priming task, however, was not reliable. In addition, a correlation was found between the distance effects in the comparison task and the same-different task. The priming distance effect did not correlate with the other two effects. These results suggest important differences between distance effects obtained under automatic and intentional task instructions regarding the use of them as indices of mathematical ability.

DOI: 10.1016/j.actpsy.2010.10.004
Version: za2963e q8za3 q8zb4 q8zce q8zdc q8ze7 q8zf5 q8zg3

Similar articles you may find interesting…

  1. A policy informing qualitative study to improve the process of blood product recalls and withdrawals.
    Nancy M Heddle, John Eyles, ... Bronwen R McCurdy

    Transfusion 48(12):2585-95 (2008) PMID 18764825

    Forty-five interviews were conducted. Major themes arising from the data were communication, timeliness of follow-up information, and challenges related to patient notification. The current recall and/or withdrawal process was described and a new model for the recall and/or withdrawal process was de...
  2. The Effect of Stereotype Threat on the Solving of Quantitative GRE Problems: A Mere Effort Interpretation
    J P Jamieson and S G Harkins

    Pers Soc Psychol Bull 35(10):1301-1314 (2009) PMID 19407004

    The mere effort account argues that stereotype threat motivates participants to want to perform well, which potentiates prepotent responses. If the prepotent response is correct, performance is facilitated. If incorrect and participants do not know, or lack the knowledge or time required for correcti...